The Gift of Being Unchosen
Nadine had written the message three times and deleted it twice.
The third version sat there, blinking on her phone screen like it had its own heartbeat.
I don’t want to pressure you. I just need to know where I stand.
She stared at it while the kettle clicked off in the kitchen and the peppermint tea she had promised herself she would drink went cold beside her. Outside her apartment window, South Florida rain tapped the glass with that familiar island rhythm, the kind that made her think of Kingston zinc roofs, Sunday dinners, wet hibiscus, and her grandmother’s voice saying, “Child, don’t chase what God already slowing down.”
Nadine pressed her thumb against the side of the phone, not sending, not deleting.
Just holding.
That had become her talent lately.
Holding conversations in her throat.
Holding tears until after work.
Holding hope like a pot that was too hot but too precious to put down.
And somewhere in the middle of all that holding, she had begun to wonder if love was supposed to feel this heavy.
The woman who carried everyone else
Nadine Ellis was the kind of woman people called when they needed something done properly.
At church, she remembered who needed a ride, who had surgery, who liked ginger in their soup, and which auntie would smile in your face then complain that the rice and peas “needed one more likkle coconut milk.”
At work, she fixed problems before anyone realized they were problems. She had a laugh that made tired people feel less alone. She carried extra lotion in her purse, extra mints, extra safety pins, and, somehow, extra patience.
She was thirty-eight, single, Jamaican-born, and living in Miramar, though her heart still walked barefoot through her grandmother’s yard near Mandeville. She knew how to stretch a paycheck, season oxtail by instinct, pray under her breath in traffic, and send money home without announcing it to the world.
She also knew how to love quietly.
That was how she loved Andre.
Andre was not cruel. That was the part that made telling the truth difficult.
If he had been careless with her heart, Nadine could have packed anger like a suitcase and left with her dignity clicking behind her in good heels. But Andre was gentle. Thoughtful in pieces. Present in moments. The kind of man who remembered that she hated carnations, preferred yellow roses, and could not sleep if a closet door was open.
He called her “Nads,” a nickname nobody else used. When her mother had a health scare, he showed up with soup and sat on the floor assembling the little blood pressure monitor she had bought in a panic. When Nadine’s car battery died outside Publix, Andre came, sweating through his T-shirt, teasing her the whole time.
“You see? This is why you need to stop buying these fancy little yogurts and invest in jumper cables.”
“Mind your business and connect the red one to the red thing,” she told him.
He laughed, and she loved him more for it.
That was the trouble.
He gave her just enough warmth to make her heart bloom, but not enough sun to grow roots.
For two years, they had lived in the tender confusion between friendship and something more. They went to food festivals together. He carried her grocery bags. She edited his resume, helped him choose shirts for interviews, reminded him of his father’s birthday, and prayed for him when he was too tired to pray for himself.
People asked questions.
“So when unnu getting married?” Sister Paulette asked one Sunday, fanning herself with the church bulletin.
Nadine laughed too loudly. “Married? To who? Andre only come for free Sunday dinner.”
Andre grinned and raised both hands. “The jerk chicken is anointed. I can’t deny the Spirit.”
Everybody laughed.
Nadine laughed too.
Then she went home, took off her earrings, and sat on the edge of the bed with the joke still aching in her chest.
The message she could not send
The half-written message remained on her phone while her tea formed a dull skin across the top.
I just need to know where I stand.
It sounded simple. Reasonable. Adult.
Still, her thumb would not move.
Because what if he answered?
What if he said, gently, kindly, with that soft voice that always undid her, “Nadine, I care about you, but not like that”?
What if he confirmed the thing her spirit already knew?
She picked up the mug and took a sip. Cold.
“Wonderful,” she muttered. “Now even the tea reject me.”
The laugh came out small, but it saved her from crying for another minute.
On the windowsill sat a little guinep tree seedling in a clay pot. Andre had brought it to her from a Caribbean market, laughing because neither of them knew whether it would survive indoors.
“You always talking about missing yard,” he had said. “Here. Grow a piece of Jamaica.”
She had taken it like a promise.
For months, she had watered the plant every morning. Turned it toward the sun. Checked the soil with one careful finger. Moved it away from the air conditioning vent because “Caribbean people and Caribbean plants don’t like too much cold.”
The little tree grew for a while. Two glossy leaves. Then three.
Then it stopped.
No matter what she did, it remained small, green, and stubbornly still.
That evening, staring at the message, Nadine glanced at the plant and sighed.
“Look at me,” she told it. “Watering a tree that never asked to be planted.”
The plant, full of wisdom and disrespect, said nothing.
She did not send the message that night.
Instead, she opened her journal.
At the top of the page, she wrote:
What am I afraid his answer will prove?
For a long time, she watched the point of the pen.
Then the words came.
That I was useful, not loved.
She put the pen down.
There it was.
Not dramatic. Not poetic. Just the bruise beneath all the other bruises.
Years before Andre, before Miramar, before the church committees and the respectable blouses, there had been a father who came and went according to his own weather. Nadine had learned young that love could be seasonal. Bring good report cards, be helpful, don’t make trouble, don’t cry too much, and maybe someone would stay.
She became easy to praise and hard to hold.
She became dependable.
She became the woman who could sense disappointment before it entered the room.
With Andre, she had fallen into an old rhythm without noticing. She cooked. She listened. She encouraged. She softened herself around his silences. She told herself patience was love. She told herself timing was the issue. She told herself men needed space.
Some of that was true.
Not all truth is the whole truth.
The deeper truth sat on the journal page, plain as morning.
She was tired of auditioning for a place in someone’s heart.
Andre had a good heart, but not her name on it
Three days later, Andre invited her to walk at the beach after work.
The rain had cleared. The sky was pink and gold in the way God sometimes paints the evening like He is trying to calm everybody down at once. Families packed up coolers. Children chased gulls. A man with a portable speaker played old Beres Hammond, and Nadine nearly laughed at the danger of it.
Caribbean love songs had no mercy.
Andre walked beside her, hands in his pockets. He looked tired. Not just work tired. Soul tired.
“Everything all right?” she asked.
He kicked at the sand. “Trying to be.”
They walked in silence for a while.
Nadine knew his silences. This one had weight.
When they reached a quiet stretch near the water, he stopped.
“Nads.”
Her stomach tightened.
“Yes?”
He looked out at the ocean instead of at her. “I value you. You know that, right?”
There it was, opening like a door she did not want to enter.
She nodded, though her throat had gone dry.
“You’re one of the best people in my life,” he said. “You’ve been there for me in ways I don’t even know how to explain.”
The old Nadine would have rushed in to comfort him.
The old Nadine would have said, “You don’t have to explain.”
The old Nadine would have saved him from the discomfort of hurting her.
This Nadine stayed quiet.
Andre rubbed his hand over his face. “I know people assume things about us. And I know maybe I let it feel like more sometimes. I didn’t mean to play with you.”
“I know,” she said.
And she did know.
That made it ache differently.
He finally looked at her. His eyes were kind. Sad. Honest.
“I love you,” he said. “But I don’t think I love you the way you deserve to be loved.”
The words did not knock her down.
They landed like something she had been carrying finally stepped out of her arms.
The first feeling was humiliation. Sharp. Hot. Immediate.
Why not me?
The question rose with all its cousins.
Was I too much?
Not enough?
Too available?
Too strong?
Too old to be starting again?
Was I only a soft place for him to rest until his real life arrived?
Nadine looked down at her sandals sinking into wet sand.
A wave came in and touched her toes, gentle as a hand.
Andre spoke again. “I’m sorry.”
She believed him.
That was the inconvenient mercy.
He was sorry. He had cared. He had shown up in real ways. He had also not chosen her.
Both could be true.
Nadine inhaled slowly, tasting salt, sunscreen, and the faint smoke of somebody’s beach grill. She thought of her journal. The cold tea. The little guinep tree. A Tree That Could Not Grow, not because it was ugly, not because it was worthless, but because the place and the planting were not right.
“You didn’t do this alone,” she said.
Andre frowned. “What do you mean?”
“I kept reading more into things because I wanted there to be more.”
He shook his head. “I should have been clearer.”
“Yes,” she said softly. “You should have.”
He accepted that without defense.
For a moment, neither moved.
Then Nadine did something that surprised them both.
She laughed.
Not because it was funny. Because the alternative was folding into the sand like wet laundry.
Andre blinked. “What?”
“I was thinking,” she said, wiping under one eye, “that I have been watering a whole tree you never asked me to plant.”
His face broke into a sad smile. “Nads.”
“No, listen. I bought fertilizer, moved it near sunlight, named it in my spirit, probably claimed it on my imaginary tax return.”
He laughed then, quiet and guilty.
She laughed too, and one tear fell anyway.
The laughter made room for grief without letting grief swallow her whole.
The choice that felt like kindness and loss
That night, Nadine did not ask Andre to change his mind.
She wanted to.
The wanting was human.
She wanted to remind him of every late-night conversation, every prayer, every favor, every time he had leaned on her as if her heart was a place he could live.
She wanted to ask how a man could feel so safe and not be home.
She wanted to stand there with a list and make a case for herself.
Instead, she chose not to perform.
That was the meaningful choice.
Not a grand speech. Not blocking him in anger. Not pretending she was above heartbreak.
She simply told the truth.
“I need to step back,” she said.
Andre nodded slowly. “I understand.”
“I don’t know for how long.”
“I understand that too.”
“I can’t be your almost.”
His jaw tightened. “I never wanted you to feel like that.”
“I know. But I do.”
The ocean moved beside them, endless and unconcerned, while two people who cared about each other learned how to stop hurting each other with closeness.
Andre asked if he could hug her.
Nadine thought about it.
Her body wanted that hug the way a thirsty throat wants water. Her spirit knew water can still drown you if you keep standing in the wrong place.
“Not tonight,” she said.
The words trembled, but they stood.
He nodded. “Okay.”
They walked back to the parking lot with space between them.
Not cold space.
Honest space.
When Nadine got into her car, she did not start it right away. She watched Andre climb into his truck. He sat there too, head bowed.
For one tender second, she almost rolled down her window and called out to him.
Instead, she placed both hands on the steering wheel and whispered, “God, help me not turn pain into a steering wheel.”
Then she drove home.
The first morning after
Heartbreak recovery did not make Nadine elegant at first.
The next morning, she woke up with one eye puffy and a bonnet leaning like it had survived spiritual warfare.
She looked in the mirror and said, “Well. Good morning to everybody except emotional maturity.”
Then she brushed her teeth and cried anyway.
Healing after rejection, she learned, was not one brave decision. It was a hundred small decisions that looked unimpressive from the outside.
Do not reread old texts before breakfast.
Do not check if he watched your story.
Do not interpret silence as a secret message.
Do not turn memory into evidence.
Do not eat only plantain chips and call it dinner, although she did lose that battle one Thursday night and decided grace could cover sodium.
She told her closest friend, Keisha, who came over with curry chicken, white rice, and the kind of face that said she was ready to dislike Andre on Nadine’s behalf.
“But he didn’t do me dirty,” Nadine said, curled on the couch.
Keisha narrowed her eyes. “How inconvenient.”
“I know.”
“So I can’t cuss him?”
“Not properly.”
Keisha sighed and opened the food container. “Fine. I will only cuss the situation.”
“Thank you for your service.”
They ate with paper plates on their laps.
Keisha listened as Nadine talked. Not just about Andre, but about her father. About usefulness. About how easy it was to confuse being needed with being chosen.
Keisha did not rush her.
When Nadine finished, Keisha said, “Maybe this is self-love too, you know.”
“What?”
“Letting somebody be honest without punishing yourself for the answer.”
Nadine sat with that.
Outside the window, the guinep seedling leaned toward the light, still small, still green.
A week passed.
Then two.
Andre texted once.
I hope you’re okay. No need to respond. Just wanted you to know I’m praying for you.
Nadine read it in the grocery store between the callaloo and Scotch bonnet peppers.
Her chest tightened.
The old self reached for the phone.
The healing self placed the phone back in her bag and said aloud, “Not in aisle seven, Satan.”
An elderly woman nearby looked over.
Nadine smiled politely and picked up a bundle of thyme like nothing had happened.
Love without resentment
Nadine did not stop loving Andre all at once.
That surprised her.
She had imagined release as a door slamming shut. Instead, it felt more like loosening her fingers one by one.
Some days, she missed him with a clean ache.
Other days, she felt foolish and had to remind herself feelings are not foolish just because they are not returned.
Unrequited love had embarrassed her at first. The phrase itself sounded like a private failure, a fancy way of saying, He didn’t want you back.
But slowly, something softer appeared.
Unrequited love was painful, yes. It was also protection.
It protected Andre from living inside a promise he could not make with his whole heart.
It protected Nadine from building a home where she would spend years trying to earn what should have been freely given.
It protected their love and friendship from becoming a quiet resentment.
Because appreciation is not the same as chosen love.
Need is not the same as devotion.
Comfort is not the same as covenant.
A person can care deeply and still not be able to offer the kind of love that builds a life. That truth did not excuse confusion, but it made room for compassion.
Nadine began to feel the difference between rejection and release.
Rejection said, You were not enough.
Release said, This was not yours to carry.
Rejection made her compare herself to women she had never met.
Release invited her back into her own body, her own laughter, her own evenings.
She returned to things she had neglected. She joined the Saturday morning walking group at church and discovered that half the women were there for exercise and half were there to discuss everybody’s questionable relationship choices under the covering of “fresh air.”
She started cooking for herself again, not leftovers from meals made with Andre in mind. Brown stew snapper. Pumpkin rice. Cucumber salad with vinegar and pepper. Soup on Saturdays, because some rituals deserved to stay.
She moved the single chair by the window, the one where she used to sit waiting for his calls, and turned it slightly toward the plant.
Then one evening, she sat there with her journal open.
The page was clean.
At the top, she wrote:
What did this love teach me?
This time, the answers did not come like accusations.
They came like rain.
It taught me I can love with depth.
It taught me I can be honest.
It taught me longing is not a command.
It taught me friendship needs boundaries when one heart starts bleeding.
It taught me my worth does not shrink because someone cannot choose me.
It taught me to notice seamless care, the kind that does not make me beg for presence.
It taught me that love should not require a sales pitch.
She paused, then added:
It taught me to respect his right to choose himself, and mine too.
That line made her cry.
Not the desperate crying from before. This was quieter. Sacred release. The kind of crying that rinses the room inside you.
The day the tree taught her back
By spring, the guinep seedling had not grown much taller.
Nadine stood before it one Saturday morning, hands on hips.
“All this filtered water and encouragement, and you still giving me two and a half leaves?”
The plant remained unmoved.
She laughed, then touched one leaf with her fingertip.
It was alive. Just not becoming what she imagined.
That was when she understood.
She had been measuring the plant by a future it had never promised her.
Maybe it would never be a tall tree. Maybe it would stay small. Maybe one day she would take it to a community garden where it could have more sun and soil. Maybe its purpose was not fruit. Maybe it had only come to show her the shape of her own hope.
That afternoon, she drove to a nursery and bought a larger pot, not for the guinep tree, but for a basil plant, rosemary, and thyme. Herbs she could use. Fragrance she could touch. Green things that fit the life she was actually living.
She did not throw the guinep away.
She placed it on the balcony where it could receive honest light.
That evening, Andre called.
Nadine let it ring once. Twice.
Her stomach fluttered, but not with panic this time.
She answered.
“Hi,” she said.
“Hi, Nads.”
His voice still had the power to move something in her. She did not judge herself for that.
He asked how she was.
She told the truth. “Better. Still tender sometimes, but better.”
“I’m glad.”
They were quiet.
Then Andre said, “I miss my friend.”
Nadine closed her eyes.
There it was. The tender place.
“I miss my friend too,” she said. “But I can’t return to what we were.”
“I know.”
“If friendship comes back, it has to be different. Clear. Kind. Boundaried.”
“I want that, if you do.”
“I don’t know yet.”
He accepted that.
No pressure. No persuasion. No soft pulling on old threads.
For the first time, Nadine felt something like relief in the space between them.
Not perfection.
Not romance restored.
Not a movie ending with rain and apologies and swelling music.
Just two adults standing in honesty, letting love change shape without forcing it to become something false.
Before they hung up, Andre said, “You really are one of the best people I know.”
Nadine smiled sadly. “I know.”
He laughed, surprised.
She did too.
Not because his words were enough.
Because she no longer needed them to prove what God had already placed in her.
The relief that came after release
Months later, Nadine sat by the same window where the half-written message had once glowed on her phone.
The chair was still there.
The tea was hot this time.
The phone was quiet.
The guinep plant lived on the balcony, stubborn and small, catching morning light. The herbs were thriving nearby, especially the thyme, which had taken over like a Jamaican auntie in a church kitchen.
Nadine opened her journal and returned to the page where she had once written, That I was useful, not loved.
Under it, she wrote a new line.
I was loving, and that matters.
She did not need to call the love meaningless just because it had not been returned in the way she wanted.
That was the gift of being unchosen.
It had hurt her, yes.
It had also freed her.
Being unchosen by Andre gave her back the right to choose herself without bitterness. It taught her that honest love does not demand a hostage. It does not beg a heart into presence. It does not build a future on hints, almosts, and borrowed tenderness.
Love, real love, has choice in it.
So does self-worth.
Nadine still believed love could come again. Not despite what happened, but because of it. The beauty of loving honestly proved her heart had not turned to stone. It proved she could give warmth, loyalty, prayer, laughter, patience, and care.
Next time, she would not offer those gifts as an audition.
She would offer them where love had room to answer.
She lifted her tea and smiled toward the balcony.
“Grow if you want,” she told the little tree. “No pressure.”
For once, she meant it.
If this story stirred something tender in you, let it lead you back to poetry, reflection, and healing. Purchase Poetic Emotions by Racquel R. Reece and sit with the words that inspired this meditation, the poem Unrequited Love, sacred release, and the quiet strength of choosing yourself.
Comments